Interdisciplinary Colloquium
Dr. Itai Bassi, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
As part of the department’s weekly research colloquium,
held every Thursday from 16:15 to 17:45 in the Webb Building (Room 103),
the following lecture by Dr. Itai Bassi (Ben-Gurion University of the Negev) will take place:
Weak Crossover, Competition, and Intervention
Abstract:
Weak Crossover (WCO), exemplified in (1), is the surprising restriction against certain cases of pronominal binding in displacement contexts (Postal 1971).
(1) *Which boy1 will his1 mother scold t1?
The purpose of this talk is to revive, refine, and argue for a largely forgotten proposal about WCO due to Ruys 1994, according to which (W)CO effects are a result of a global Economy principle `Shortest Move’ which compares competing derivations of the same interpretation and (roughly) seeks to minimize the movement dependencies involved in reaching that interpretation. On that approach, (1) competes and loses to the semantically equivalent which boy1’s mother scolded him1?
I will defend a version of this approach based on its ability to account for an old and hitherto unexplained WCO puzzle due to Postal (1993): WCO effects disappear when focus-sensitive operators (only, even) are added as in (2).
(2)
a. Which boy1 will only his1 MOTHER scold t1?
b. Which boy1 will even his1 MOTHER scold t1?
I will argue that (2) is good per Shortest Move, because the competitor in which the bound pronoun and the trace switch places is independently ill-formed, due to a configuration of Focus Intervention (Li & Law 1016, a.o.). (2) are therefore ok because nothing blocks them.
I will present a number of further predictions that the theory makes, both in focus contexts and outside of them, and will attempt to corroborate them. Challenges remain, some of which will be discussed.
Relevant reference:
Ruys 1994. A Global Economy Analysis of Weak Crossover
All are welcome!
